Rob Gemmel 's overtime goal beats Providence in The Comeback, 6 March 1979
| Season | Date | Player | Opponent | Time | Notes | |
| 1996 (2) | 11/18/95 | Brad Chartrand | at Dartmouth | 1:57 | ||
| 02/02/96 | Jason Dailey | at Princeton | 3:29 | |||
| 1997 (1) | 12/27/96 | David Adler | vs Providence | 50:41 | Syracuse Invitational (3ot) | |
| 1998 (1) | 01/19/98 | Ryan Moynihan | at Colgate | 3:53 | ||
| 2000 (1) | 11/06/99 | Denis Ladouceur | at Union | 3:59 | ||
| 2001 (4) | 12/27/00 | David Kozier | vs Ohio State | 1:38 | ||
| 01/12/01 | Mark McRae | at Vermont | 4:46 | |||
| 02/02/01 | Krzysztof Wieckowski | at Brown | 1:17 | |||
| 03/09/01 | David Kozier | Princeton | 7:25 | ECAC First Round | ||
| 2003 (3) | 12/07/02 | Ryan Vesce | at Western Michigan | 1:30 |
||
| 03/22/03 | Sam Paolini | vs Harvard | 1:23 |
ECAC F | ||
| 03/30/03 | Matt McRae | vs BC | 1:09 |
NCAA QF | ||
| 2004 (1) | 12/28/03 | Greg Hornby | vs Ohio State | 2:30 |
||
| 2005 (3) | 01/14/05 | Mike Iggulden | at Union | 3:08 |
Shorthanded | |
| 02/25/05 | Mike Knoepfli | at St. Lawrence | 2:31 |
|||
| 03/12/05 | Topher Scott | Clarkson | 12:00 |
ECAC QF Game 2 | ||
| 2006 (4) | 11/05/05 | Mitch Carefoot | at Brown | 3:20 |
||
| 01/27/06 | Chris Abbott | Brown | 1:50 |
|||
| 03/10/06 | Ray Sawada | Clarkson | 28:30 |
ECAC QF Game 1 (2ot) | ||
| 03/11/06 | Matt Moulson | Clarkson | 30:32 |
ECAC QF Game 2 (2ot) | ||
| 2008 (2) | 02/01/08 | Colin Greening | Colgate | 1:03 |
||
| 02/22/08 | Michael Kennedy | at Quinnipiac | 4:41 |
|||
| 2009 (3) | 02/06/09 | Evan Barlow | Quinnipiac | 2:52 |
||
| 02/28/09 | Blake Gallagher | at Brown | 2:13 |
|||
| 03/20/09 | Colin Greening | vs Princeton | 29:54 |
ECAC SF (2ot) | ||
| 2010 (1) | 10/30/09 | Joe Devin | Niagara | 1:42 |