| | October 30, 2009 | Niagara (0-4-1) |
| | Non-conference RS Game | #6 | | Cornell (1-0-0) |
| | Ithaca |
| | Niagara | 1 1 0 0 - 2 |
| | Cornell | 1 1 0 1 - 3 |
| |
| | Period | 1 |
| | 06:00 | Nia | Jason Beattie (Marc Zanette, Brent Vandenberg) |
| | 13:07 | Cor | pp | Colin Greening (Riley Nash, Sean Whitney) |
| |
| | Period | 2 |
| | 01:53 | Cor | pp | Patrick Kennedy (Riley Nash, Blake Gallagher) |
| | 16:58 | Nia | pp | Egor Mironov (Chris Moran, Tyler Gotto) |
| |
| | Period | 4 |
| | 01:42 | Cor | Joe Devin (Colin Greening, Nick D'Agostino) |
| |
| | Saves |
| | Cor | W | Ben Scrivens | 61:39 | 28 | x | 30 |
| | Nia | L | Adam Avramenko | 61:37 | 38 | x | 41 |