| | December 14, 1957 | Lehigh (--) |
| | Pre-conference Game | Cornell (1-0-0) |
| | Ithaca |
| | Lehigh | 0 0 3 - 3 |
| | Cornell | 9 2 5 - 16 |
| |
| | Period | 1 |
| | 00:13 | Cor | Roger Eastman (John Gillies) |
| | 01:40 | Cor | John Gillies (John Vollbrecht) |
| | 06:40 | Cor | Roger Eastman (John Vollbrecht) |
| | 07:34 | Cor | John Gillies (John Vollbrecht) |
| | 12:20 | Cor | Roger Eastman (John Gillies, John Coppage) |
| | 12:39 | Cor | John Gillies (John Vollbrecht) |
| | 15:52 | Cor | Dave Forman (Lane Montesano) |
| | 16:22 | Cor | Lane Montesano (unassisted) |
| | 16:37 | Cor | Henry Yates (Dave Forman) |
| |
| | Period | 2 |
| | 15:20 | Cor | Lane Montesano (unassisted) |
| | 17:59 | Cor | Henry Yates (unassisted) |
| |
| | Period | 3 |
| | 01:47 | Cor | John Gillies (unassisted) |
| | 01:56 | Cor | Paul Marcus (unassisted) |
| | 07:58 | Leh | Crichton (Debus) |
| | 09:38 | Cor | John Gillies (John Vollbrecht) |
| | 09:59 | Leh | Schopp (Dillman, Birrell) |
| | 10:22 | Cor | John Coppage (unassisted) |
| | 15:47 | Cor | Roger Eastman (unassisted) |
| | 19:55 | Leh | Birrell (Fawcett) |
| |
| | Saves |
| | Cor | W | John Detwiler | 40:00 | 9 | x | 9 |
| | Cor | N | Howard Taylor | 20:00 | 5 | x | 8 |
| | Leh | L | Gill | 60:00 | 58 | x | 74 |