| 1982 (2) | 01/23/82 | Roy Kerling | at Northeastern | |
| 02/20/82 | Joe Gallant | Maine | First 3 goals of game | |
| 1983 (3) | 01/24/83 | Duanne Moeser | Princeton | |
| 01/29/83 | Pete Natyshak | at Princeton | ||
| 02/20/83 | Duanne Moeser | at Maine | ||
| 1984 (5) | 11/26/83 | Mark Canduro | vs Colgate | Glens Falls Consy |
| 01/27/84 | Geoff Dervin | at Yale | ||
| 02/21/84 | Duanne Moeser | Yale | With Cullen below | |
| 02/21/84 | Gary Cullen | Yale | With Moeser above | |
| 02/25/84 | Duanne Moeser | at Dartmouth | All 3 on pp | |
| 1985 (4) | 12/09/84 | Pete Natyshak | Dartmouth | |
| 01/04/85 | Mark Henderson | vs McGill | 10-10 "suspension" game in Montreal | |
| 01/19/85 | Joe Nieuwendyk | Yale | ||
| 02/08/85 | Joe Nieuwendyk | St. Lawrence | ||
| 1986 (6) | 12/03/85 | Joe Nieuwendyk | at Colgate | |
| 01/03/86 | Pete Natyshak | vs British Columbia | Natural hat trick | |
| 01/24/86 | Joe Nieuwendyk | Dartmouth | Third goal in overtime | |
| 02/07/86 | Pete Natyshak | at St. Lawrence | ||
| 02/22/86 | Chris Grenier | Brown | ||
| 03/01/85 | Duanne Moeser | at RPI | ||
| 1987 (2) | 02/27/87 | Joe Nieuwendyk | RPI | Penultimate game at Cornell |
| 02/28/87 | Joe Nieuwendyk | Vermont | Final game at Cornell | |
| 1988 (3) | 01/22/88 | Pat Heaphy | at Brown | |
| 02/12/88 | Trent Andison | at Dartmouth | 4 goals | |
| 02/20/88 | Pat Heaphy | Yale | ||
| 1989 (5) | 11/11/88 | Trent Andison | Princeton | |
| 12/10/88 | Rob Levasseur | BU | ||
| 01/06/89 | Rob Levasseur | Brown | ||
| 01/27/89 | Rob Levasseur | at Army | ||
| 02/18/89 | Trent Andison | at Brown | ||
| 1990 (1) | 01/12/90 | Ross Lemon | Army | |
| 1991 (4) | 01/22/91 | Doug Derraugh | at Colgate | |
| 01/26/91 | Doug Derraugh | at Dartmouth | ||
| 01/29/91 | Ryan Hughes | BC | 4 goals | |
| 03/02/91 | Trent Andison | Colgate | ECAC QF Gm 2 | |
| 1994 (3) | 02/26/94 | Vinnie Auger | Yale | |
| 02/26/94 | Jake Karam | Yale | ||
| 03/08/94 | Geoff Lopatka | Princeton | incl. OT goal, ECAC 1R | |
| 1995 (5) | 01/06/95 | Jake Karam | at Union | |
| 01/15/95 | Tyler McManus | Army | ||
| 01/27/95 | Ryan Smart | St. Lawrence | ||
| 02/04/95 | Ryan Smart | at Dartmouth | ||
| 02/25/95 | Jake Karam | at Yale | ||
| 1996 (3) | 11/11/95 | Brad Chartrand | Harvard | |
| 12/10/95 | P. C. Drouin | at Union | ||
| 02/17/96 | Kyle Knopp | at Brown | ||
| 1999 (1) | 11/13/98 | David Kozier | at Harvard | |
| 2003 (1) | 02/07/03 | Matt Moulson | Dartmouth | |
| 2004 (3) | 11/08/03 | Ryan Vesce | at Princeton | 7 points |
| 01/09/04 | Matt Moulson | at Harvard | ||
| 03/12/04 | Mike Knoepfli | Clarkson | ECAC QF Gm 1 | |
| 2005 (1) | 02/19/05 | Matt Moulson | Union | |
| 2008 (1) | 02/29/08 | Colin Greening | Dartmouth | |
| 2011 (1) | 01/22/11 | Tyler Roeszler | Colgate | |
| 2017 (2) | 11/12/16 | Mitch Vanderlaan | at Yale | |
| 01/13/17 | Jeff Malott | at Princeton | ||
| 2018 (3) | 11/17/17 | Noah Bauld | St. Lawrence | |
| 12/30/17 | Kyle Betts | Canisus | ||
| 01/27/18 | Anthony Angello | at Harvard | 3-0 game, final goal at 19:59 of 3rd | |
| 2020 (2) | 11/09/19 | Morgan Barron | Yale | |
| 02/29/20 | Ben Berard | Clarkson | ||
| 2022 (3) | 11/06/21 | Ben Berard | at Dartmouth | |
| 11/13/21 | Max Andreev | RPI | 4-2-6 | |
| 12/03/21 | Matt Stienburg | at St. Lawrence | Natural hat trick | |
| 2023 (1) | 11/26/22 | Dalton Bancroft | vs UConn | MSG |
| 2024 (1) | 01/19/24 | Jonathan Castagna | Princeton |