Not including consolation games

| Season | Rd | Opponent | Coach |
| 1966 | QF | BC | Harkness |
| SF | BU | Harkness | |
| 1967 | QF | Brown | Harkness |
| SF | BC | Harkness | |
| F | BU | Harkness | |
| 1968 | QF | Princeton | Harkness |
| SF | BU | Harkness | |
| F | BC | Harkness | |
| 1969 | QF | St. Lawrence | Harkness |
| SF | BU | Harkness | |
| F | Harvard | Harkness | |
| 1970 | QF | St. Lawrence | Harkness |
| SF | Harvard | Harkness | |
| F | Clarkson | Harkness (14) | |
| 1971 | QF | Providence | Bertrand |
| 1972 | QF | Providence | Bertrand |
| SF | UNH | Bertrand | |
| 1973 | QF | RPI | Bertrand |
| SF | Clarkson | Bertrand | |
| F | BC | Bertrand | |
| 1974 | QF | St. Lawrence | Bertrand |
| 1975 | QF | UNH | Bertrand |
| 1976 | QF | Clarkson | Bertrand |
| 1977 | QF | RPI | Bertrand |
| 1979 | QF | Providence | Bertrand |
| 1980 | QF | BC | Bertrand |
| SF | Providence | Bertrand | |
| F | Dartmouth | Bertrand | |
| 1981 | QF | Maine | Bertrand |
| SF | Colgate | Bertrand (16) | |
| 1985 | QF | Yale | Reycroft |
| 1986 | QF | Vermont | Reycroft |
| SF | Yale | Reycroft | |
| F | Clarkson | Reycroft (4) | |
| 1989 | QF | Clarkson | McCutcheon |
| 1990 | QF | Harvard | McCutcheon |
| 1991 | QF | Colgate | McCutcheon |
| 1992 | QF | Yale | McCutcheon |
| SF | Clarkson | McCutcheon | |
| 1994 | Prelim | Princeton | McCutcheon |
| 1995 | Prelim | St. Lawrence | McCutcheon (8) |
| 1996 | QF | Colgate | Schafer |
| SF | Clarkson | Schafer | |
| F | Harvard | Schafer | |
| 1997 | QF | Harvard | Schafer |
| SF | RPI | Schafer | |
| F | Clarkson | Schafer | |
| 1998 | QF | RPI | Schafer |
| 2000 | QF | Harvard | Schafer |
| PIG | Clarkson | Schafer | |
| 2001 | QF | Princeton | Schafer |
| SF | Harvard | Schafer | |
| 2002 | QF | Yale | Schafer |
| SF | RPI | Schafer | |
| 2003 | QF | RPI | Schafer |
| SF | Brown | Schafer | |
| F | Harvard | Schafer | |
| 2005 | QF | Clarkson | Schafer |
| SF | Vermont | Schafer | |
| F | Harvard | Schafer | |
| 2006 | QF | Clarkson | Schafer |
| SF | Colgate | Schafer | |
| 2008 | 1R | Dartmouth | Schafer |
| QF | Union | Schafer | |
| 2009 | QF | RPI | Schafer |
| SF | Princeton | Schafer | |
| 2010 | QF | Harvard | Schafer |
| SF | Brown | Schafer | |
| F | Union | Schafer (28) |